Sunday, June 26, 2022

Some scientists say tracking wastewater for COVID-19 may pose privacy and ethics concerns. Nation World News

During the COVID-19 pandemic, wastewater monitoring and analysis became an important tool in monitoring and measuring the amount of virus in communities.

But some experts caution that the data collected from these studies may also raise privacy concerns, especially because samples are often collected from public sources without personal consent.

“Bioethics, which is what health care providers do, has historically been based on ‘do no harm’—and based on the idea of ​​informed consent,” said Steve Hrudy, professor emeritus at the University of Alberta’s Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathology. “Well, informed consent isn’t really possible for this kind of technology.”

Hrudey is chair of the National Research Advisory Group for the COVID-19 Wastewater Coalition, a non-profit group established in the spring of 2020 to help build and share information about wastewater monitoring efforts across the country .

Read Also:  GDB 41.0 Wrap Up: The Oilers down the Habs and extend their winning streak to four games

Hruday. A 2021 paper co-authored by and six other researchers recommended that wastewater monitoring programs for COVID-19 follow a list of 17 guidelines for ethical public health surveillance presented by the World Health Organization.

Those guidelines suggest that monitoring programs should adhere to four main goals: working toward the common good, equality, respect for individuals, and good governance.

“The case for maximizing the potential of this approach is compelling, but the benefits of wastewater monitoring clearly must outweigh the ethical risks to the community,” reads the paper.

poop doesn’t lie

Humans can shed the genetic material of the SARS-CoV-2 virus in the form of RNA. Sometimes the virus can be detected in samples of human wastewater before a person displays symptoms of the disease.

Read Also:  Protesters block Alberta highway near Coutts border, RCMP tells drivers to stay away

“If you’re flushing it right away, within days of being infected, that information is already being flushed down the toilet. [and] traveling to your wastewater treatment plant, where it’s being collected and analyzed, you know, us or someone like us,” said Newsha Gheli, co-founder of wastewater epidemiology company Biobot Analytics Told.

Newsha Ghaeli is the co-founder of Biobot Analytics, an American company that tests wastewater for COVID-19. (Biobot Analytics)

Gheli, who studied in Waterloo, Ont. and Montreal before co-founding Biobot in the US, said the technology used by her company can currently detect a positive case in a sample of a population of 6,500 people.

This data has become increasingly important as provinces and territories reduce access to PCR tests in late 2021, particularly as the Delta and subsequent Omicron waves saw significant spikes in reported and suspected positive cases.

Experts like Gheli say the data may be very accurate, but there is no way to identify a person, even if they detect a single positive case.

Your stool does not contain identifying information, such as fingerprints, as it was.

“When we get a positive test, we don’t know what it came from. You know, it’s like saying, ‘Oh, we have a lot of cars on 401s today.'” You have no idea who is driving those cars,” said Kim Gilbride, a professor and molecular microbiologist in Toronto Metropolitan University’s Gilbride Lab for Wastewater Monitoring.

Some scientists say tracking wastewater for COVID-19 may pose privacy and ethics concerns. Nation World News
A pellet obtained from wastewater material is seen in the Gilbride Lab at Toronto Metropolitan University. (Peter Mitten/CBC)

sludge life, feces pellets

Gilbride’s lab analyzes samples of sewage that are delivered from the Greater Toronto Area: some from hospitals, long-term care homes, while others come from the Humber wastewater treatment plant.

Those bottles are mostly filled with cloudy water, but some of them are more opaque and are labeled “sludge”.

“When you open one of them – yes, you have to duck for cover,” said Babneet Channa, a research assistant who helps process the samples.

Some scientists say tracking wastewater for COVID-19 may pose privacy and ethics concerns. Nation World News
Nora Danna is a post-doctoral researcher who works in the Gilbride Lab for Wastewater Monitoring at Toronto Metropolitan University. (Peter Mitten/CBC)

Channa and another assistant, Matthew Sentilly, work mostly with equipment that is fitted with a fume hood to expel those odors. They put the samples into test tubes that spin inside a centrifuge – rendering the sludge into a relatively inert, pea-sized pellet for analysis.

“It’s anonymous. We don’t really, like, go after people and say, ‘It’s you,’ you know, or ‘This is your house,'” said Nora Danna, a post-doctoral researcher who also works in the laboratory.

Data can help or hurt people in the neighborhood: Hruday

That’s not enough to assuage the concerns of Hrudy, who says “you can zero in on very small areas” if samples are identified and collected from specific sewer networks in a city.

With narrow enough data, public health officials can deploy to neighborhoods to prevent the outbreak from spreading further. But it can also be misused to stigmatize the people who live there — or worse, Hruday warned.

It is not even purely theoretical, he said.

there has been Cases in Hong Kong and Singapore Where wastewater monitoring has been used in apartment buildings and then officials track positive samples from individual apartments, Hrude said.

“The officers showed up and said, ‘Well, you know, you have a case here and you need to get tested,'” he said.

“Now, you could argue that there is a public health rationale for this. But you can see that a slippery slope is possible.”

Some scientists say tracking wastewater for COVID-19 may pose privacy and ethics concerns. Nation World News
Research assistant Babneet Channa handles bottles of wastewater samples at Toronto Metropolitan University’s Gilbride Lab. He’s mostly working under the fume hood, which takes away the smell. (Peter Mitten/CBC)

Hrudy also said he has seen a draft research proposal suggesting that it may be possible to chart the infection rates of neighborhoods with COVID or other traceable diseases in blocks.

“It was in enough detail that you could almost identify the street address,” he said.

However, he insisted that the proposal was theoretical – presenting only what may be possible – and did not know whether anyone in Canada had attempted it or used it to provide access to private citizens’ data. .

“Health officials are bound, at least in Alberta and I suspect in most provinces, by very strict privacy laws relating to personally identifiable health records,” he wrote. sunday magazine In a follow-up email.

He is not alone in raising these concerns.

A 2021 article in the European Journal of Law and Technology, by Dutch scientist Bart van der Sloot, shows a potential future use that almost read like science fiction: wastewater monitoring robots that can crawl through residential pipes , can take samples from the same road or even one. single house.

Gheli agrees that there is a need to lay down a more definitive ethical ground for how wastewater monitoring is used – and the latter instead. But we’re not there yet, she said.

“I think within a year or two we will be in a different place, because it is absolutely necessary for us, I think, to talk through and solve these difficult questions,” she said.

With files from Peter Mitten. Radio segment produced by Peter Mitten.

Nation World News Desk
Nation World News Desk
Nation World News is the fastest emerging news website covering all the latest news, world’s top stories, science news entertainment sports cricket’s latest discoveries, new technology gadgets, politics news, and more.
Latest news
Related news
- Advertisement -